These bagels were so good! The dude working there was really chill and loved telling us about the menu. The bagels weren't too bad for the price but could have been a little cheaper.

Conveniently located just north of Times Square area on 8th Ave., Pick a bagel offers quick service and indoor and outdoor seating area. Healthy options, such as fruit available as well as pastry goodies available. Dedicated personnel to constantly keeping the place picked up and wiped down offers a clean shop. Fairly well organized, and quick service. However, everyone in our party had a slight mistake in their order. Didn't affect the quality but clearly shows there's some opportunity in their ordering to prep process! Nice selection of smears. Bagels were very good and we've tried a handful of shops throughout the city this week. This falls into number four out of six.

This was a pretty good bagel spot. We came twice during our trip to New York, and we liked it. They didn't have much variety for the bagels and cream cheese, but we were happy with our bagels. They are very generous with the cream cheese. It's a really busy place, and we took our bagels to go both times we came. They do have some tables to sit inside and outside, but it's not very spacious and we didn't want to be close to people. It's a cool place, would come back!

Bombbbb / delicious lox bagel special Kinda pricey but worth it $21 Stuffed with cream cheese, tomato, capers, onion Service was quick & efficient during early morning rush Corner location across from walgreens; spots to sit/stand, Will be back!

Pick A Bagel is in a word, AWESOME. If you are VEGAN and are near the Ed Sullivan Theatre in New York City, well there is only one Bagel spot to visit. The variety of VEGAN cream cheese options is the most I have EVER seen in any establishment I have ever visited. FULL DISCLOSURE, it is a hole in a hole-in-a-wall kind of place but the atmosphere, staff, and prices are a WIN-WIN proposition people. I had the everything bagel with the VEGAN TOFU SCALLION cream cheese. Be advised they make the bagels here as sandwiches so there is an INSANE amount of cream cheese on the Bagels. I just took some off to enjoy the bagel as much as I did the cream cheese...LOL!!! If I am ever near the theatre district again I will stop by. Eat, Drink, and Be Merry, my Friends.

This is a quick spot to grab a bagel, sandwich or salad and drink. Perfect for breakfast or lunch. We were attending a taping for The Late Show with Stephen Colbert and Pick A Bagel was around the corner from the Ed Sullivan Theater and they offered vegan cream cheese so it was a win win for us. The staff is quick and efficient and they get your order out quickly. The atmosphere is bustling but welcoming. There is a public restroom available so that's a bonus. Definitely would stop here again when in the area.

Maybe my taste buds are not sophisticated enough but I thought that this was a very regular bagel place in NYC. To be honest, the only bagel place that has really stood out to me was Absolute Bagels on UWS because of the amount of cream cheese they put into each one, but anyways. - Breakfast Burrito - Standard breakfast burrito. Wish they had put some ketchup or sauce in here so that it wouldn't be so dry. - Onion Toasted with Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese, Egg, and Bacon - This was like a breakfast burrito but in a bagel minus a few ingredients, although I like this one more because it was more "wet". I would honestly just get this version instead as it was cheaper by a few miles. I wish the cream cheese had more sundried tomato flavor. Overall, not a bad bagel place although also not particularly memorable. I will say that despite there looking like there's no seats in the restaurant, there was actually plenty as people got up and left pretty quickly.